by Jamie Pantastico | Dec 29, 2025 | Israel and Bible Prophecy |
Did Dispensationalism Come from a Basement in the 1800s? A Biblical Response
In recent months, accusations have intensified against believers who affirm God’s covenant faithfulness to Israel. One of the most common claims is that so-called “Christian Zionism” or dispensational theology was “created in someone’s basement in the 1800s,” often attributed to C. I. Scofield.
That claim is repeated frequently.
It is also historically false and theologically evasive.
Scofield Did Not Create Dispensational Truth
- C.I. Scofield did not invent the distinction between Israel and the Church. He did not create dispensations, nor did he originate the belief that God will fulfill His promises to Israel.
Scofield compiled and systematized biblical distinctions already present in Scripture—particularly those revealed through the Apostle Paul.
If later clarification invalidates doctrine, then:
- The Trinity collapses
- Justification by faith alone becomes suspect
- The canon of Scripture itself becomes questionable
Truth is not determined by when it is articulated, but by whether it is biblical.
The Israel–Church Distinction Comes from Paul, Not Scofield
The real issue is not Scofield.
The issue is Romans 9–11.
Paul explicitly teaches:
- God has not cast away His people (Romans 11:1)
- Israel’s blindness is partial and temporary (Romans 11:25)
- Israel’s fall brought salvation to the Gentiles (Romans 11:11)
- Israel’s calling is irrevocable (Romans 11:29)
- God Himself committed Israel to disobedience so He might have mercy on all (Romans 11:32)
Rejecting Israel’s future is not rejecting Scofield.
It is rejecting Paul.
Blaming Bible-Believing Christians for Middle Eastern Christian Decline Is False
The decline of Christian communities in the Middle East is tragic—but it did not begin with American evangelicals or dispensational theology.
Middle Eastern Christians have suffered for centuries under:
- Islamic domination
- Dhimmi systems
- Civil wars
- Islamist extremism
- Economic collapse and emigration
Blaming believers who affirm God’s covenant faithfulness is not analysis—it is scapegoating.
Christianity is not preserved by geography.
The Church is not territorial.
Our citizenship is in heaven (Philippians 3:20).
Supporting Israel Is Theological— Not Political
Affirming God’s promises to Israel does not mean endorsing every action of a modern secular government.
Biblical support for Israel is rooted in:
- Covenant
- Scripture
- God’s character
Not nationalism.
Not politics.
Not ideology.
The Real Issue
This debate is not ultimately about politics or Palestine.
It is about whether:
- God keeps His promises
- Romans 11 means what it says
- Paul’s teaching still matters
That is why Scripture is often avoided.
That is why Scofield is attacked.
That is why accusations replace exegesis.
“For God has committed them all to disobedience, that He might have mercy on all.”
— Romans 11:32
That truth did not come from a basement.
It came from the risen Lord, revealed through the Apostle Paul.
Footnotes
- Distinctions between Israel and the Church appear explicitly in Romans 9–11 and Ephesians 3
- Early church fathers debated Israel’s role long before Scofield
- The Reformers recovered soteriology, not eschatology
- Doctrinal development ≠ doctrinal invention
by Jamie Pantastico | Dec 27, 2025 | Verse-by-Verse Bible Studies |
📖 Passage Breakdown — Amos 3:3
“Can two walk together, unless they are agreed?”
📬 Reader Request:
This Passage Breakdown was requested by Sam R, from Tustin, California who recently asked about Amos 3:3.
His question was about application today? The answer is in this post. I’m grateful for every question that helps shape this series.
This series reaches thousands of people around the world daily. Praise God.
📜 Background, Setting & Purpose
✍️ Author
Amos, a shepherd and fig farmer from Tekoa, called by God to prophesy.
👥 Written To
The northern kingdom of Israel (often called Ephraim), during a time of prosperity, moral decay, and spiritual rebellion.
⏲️ When
Approximately 760–750 B.C., during the reign of Jeroboam II, before the Assyrian captivity.
🌍 Setting & Purpose of Amos (book-level)
Amos is a book of divine confrontation.
God sends Amos to declare:
- Israel’s covenant unfaithfulness
- God’s coming judgment
- The certainty of divine accountability
- That privilege does not cancel responsibility
Amos is not written to Gentiles. It is for our learning!
It is not written to the Church.
It is written to God’s covenant nation under the Mosaic Law.
📖 Chapter 3 Focus
Amos 3 explains why judgment is coming.
God explains that His actions are not random, harsh, or unjust. They are the result of broken agreement between Himself and Israel.
Amos 3:3 is the foundational principle for everything that follows.
✨ Phrase-by-Phrase Breakdown
“Can two walk together…”
“Walk” in Scripture often refers to:
- Conduct
- Fellowship
- Relationship
- Shared direction
This is not about a casual encounter.
It describes an ongoing journey together.
In context, the “two” are:
This is covenant language.
“…unless they are agreed?”
“Agreed” means:
- To meet by appointment
- To be in harmony
- To share terms
- To walk on the same basis
God had clearly established the terms of His relationship with Israel through the Mosaic Covenant.
Blessing was promised for obedience.
Judgment was promised for disobedience.
Israel broke the agreement.
God did not.
The question is rhetorical.
The implied answer is no.
❌ What This Verse Does Not Mean
- Not a general proverb about friendship.
- Not a reminder to “find like-minded people.”
- Not a Church-Age instruction about Christian unity.
- Not a verse teaching ecumenism or compromise.
While it contains a principle that can be applied carefully, its primary meaning is covenantal, not devotional.
✅ What It Does Mean
- God does not act arbitrarily.
- Judgment follows broken agreement.
- Israel cannot expect covenant blessings while rejecting covenant terms.
- God’s prophets are warning Israel before judgment falls.
- Separation has already occurred because agreement was abandoned.
Amos 3:3 explains why God must now act.
🔗 Immediate Context (Amos 3:1–8)
- v.1 — Israel singled out as uniquely accountable
- v.2 — “You only have I known… therefore I will punish you”
- v.4–6 — A series of cause-and-effect illustrations
- v.7 — God reveals His plans to the prophets
- v.8 — The prophet must speak
Amos 3:3 is the starting axiom:
No agreement → no fellowship → judgment follows.
🔗 Cross-References for Going Deeper
Leviticus 26 — Covenant blessings and curses
Deuteronomy 28 — Terms of agreement
Isaiah 1:2–4 — Israel’s rebellion
Hosea 6:7 — Covenant transgression
2 Corinthians 6:14 — Principle applied carefully, not imported
🙏 Devotional Summary
Amos 3:3 reminds us that God is a God of clarity, not confusion. Fellowship with Him has always been based on agreement with what He has revealed. For Israel, that agreement was the Law. When the covenant was broken, fellowship was disrupted—and judgment followed. God’s question is not cruel; it is honest. Relationship with God has never been on human terms, but on His. When agreement is restored, fellowship follows. When it is rejected, separation is inevitable.
Bottom Line
Amos 3:3 is not about coexistence—it is about covenant faithfulness.
God does not change the terms.
He honors what He has revealed.
by Jamie Pantastico | Dec 25, 2025 | Devotionals |
🎄Christmas According to the Apostle Paul
Key Text: Galatians 4:4–5
“But when the fullness of the time had come, God sent forth His Son, born of a woman, born under the law, to redeem those who were under the law, that we might receive the adoption as sons.”
Devotional: The Purpose of His Birth
This is Paul’s only direct reference to the birth of Christ — and it is anything but sentimental.
Paul does not speak of shepherds or angels.
He does not mention a manger or a star.
He tells us why Christ was born.
Christmas, according to Paul, is not about atmosphere.
It is about timing, incarnation, law, resurrection, redemption, and adoption (our position).
“When the Fullness of the Time Had Come…” — God’s Perfect Timing
Christmas did not happen randomly.
It happened at the precise moment God had ordained — after:
- the promise in Genesis 3:15
- the covenants with Abraham and David
- centuries under the Law
- the silence between the Testaments
Every prophecy, covenant, and historical movement converged at one point in history.
Christmas declares that God is never early, never late — always exact.
“God Sent Forth His Son…” — The Eternal Son
Paul does not say God created His Son.
He says God sent Him.
This confirms what the series has shown all along:
- the Son existed before Bethlehem
- the Son is eternal
- the Son willingly entered time
The One born in Bethlehem is the same One “from everlasting” (Micah 5:2).
“Born of a Woman…” — Fully Human
Here is Genesis 3:15 in Paul’s words.
The Seed of the woman had arrived.
Jesus was truly human — not an appearance, not a myth, not a spirit.
He entered the world the same way every human does — through birth.
This qualified Him to represent humanity.
“Born Under the Law…” — Fully Accountable
This phrase is crucial.
Christ was not born outside the Law.
He was born under it.
That means:
- He submitted to it
- He obeyed it perfectly
- He fulfilled it completely
He did what no son of Adam ever could.
Christmas places Jesus inside humanity’s problem, not above it.
“To Redeem Those Who Were Under the Law…” — The Mission
This is the heart of Christmas.
Jesus was not born merely to teach.
Not merely to inspire.
Not merely to model obedience.
He was born to redeem.
To buy back.
To pay in full.
To satisfy the demands of the Law.
To satisfy the will of the Father.
The manger points forward to the cross.
“That We Might Receive the Adoption as Sons” — The Result
Redemption was not the end goal — relationship was.
Because Christ fulfilled the Law and paid sin’s penalty for all mankind, God has opened the door of heaven and is now pouring out His grace on all—Jew and Gentile alike, with no distinction—in the form of a free 🎁gift: salvation apart from the Law, received simply by believing (faith alone) the gospel—”good news” of Christ’s death, burial, and resurrection:
- we are no longer slaves
- we are no longer condemned
- we are no longer outsiders
We are sons.
Christmas ends not with fear, but with family.
Encouragement for this Christmas Day
Galatians 4:4–5 reminds us that Christmas is not about what we feel —
it is about what God accomplished.
The birth of Christ means:
- sin has been addressed
- the Law has been fulfilled
- redemption has been secured
- adoption has been granted
If Christ was born exactly as promised,
and died exactly as required,
then every promise that remains will also be fulfilled.
Final Reading Plan
- Genesis 3:15 — The promise of the Seed
- Isaiah 53 — The purpose of the suffering
- Luke 2:1–20 — The birth itself
- Galatians 4:4–5 — The meaning of Christmas
- Revelation 19:11–16 — The return of the King
Closing Thought
Christmas is the moment God stepped into history to rescue those trapped under sin and the Law.
Born of a woman.
Born under the Law.
Sent to redeem.
Raised to adopt. (Resurrection Power)
That is Christmas.
And that is the gospel.
← Previous | 📖 Series Home |
by Jamie Pantastico | Dec 24, 2025 | Devotionals |
Key Text: Luke 2:25–38
“For my eyes have seen Your salvation
Which You have prepared before the face of all peoples;
A light to bring revelation to the Gentiles,
And the glory of Your people Israel.”
Devotional: When Waiting Meets Fulfillment
Theme Connection:
- Genesis 3:15 promised a Redeemer.
- Abraham preserved the Seed.
- David was promised a King and a throne.
- Isaiah foretold His birth and identity.
- Luke 1–2 announced and revealed the Child.
Now, in the temple at Jerusalem, we meet two people who represent faithful Israel waiting patiently for God to keep His word.
Simeon and Anna stand at the intersection of promise and fulfillment.
Context & Connection
Luke introduces Simeon as:
“Just and devout, waiting for the Consolation of Israel, and the Holy Spirit was upon him.”
The phrase “Consolation of Israel” is deeply prophetic. It refers to Israel’s long-awaited Messiah — the One who would comfort, redeem, and restore the nation.
For centuries, Israel had waited:
- through exile
- through silence
- through oppression
- through unanswered longing
Simeon represents the faithful remnant — those who believed God would still keep His promises.
And God did.
Devotional Insight
1. Waiting Is Not Wasted When It Is Anchored in God’s Promise
Simeon waited his entire life — but not aimlessly.
The Holy Spirit had revealed to him that he would not die before seeing the Lord’s Christ. His waiting was hope-filled, Spirit-guided, and expectant.
True biblical waiting is not passive — it is confident trust in God’s timing.
2. “My eyes have seen Your salvation” — Salvation Is a Person
Simeon does not say:
- “I’ve seen a plan”
- “I’ve seen a movement”
- “I’ve seen a system”
He says:
“My eyes have seen Your salvation.”
Salvation is not abstract.
Salvation is not a ritual.
Salvation is a Person — the Child in his arms.
Jesus is not only the means of salvation.
He is salvation.
3. “A light to bring revelation to the Gentiles…”
This is profound.
At the very beginning of Jesus’ earthly life, Simeon declares what Paul will later proclaim to the world:
The Messiah of Israel would also be the Savior of the Gentiles.
This fulfills:
- Genesis 12:3 — blessing to all nations
- Isaiah 49:6 — light to the Gentiles
Christmas was never meant to stop at Israel —
but it never bypassed Israel either.
4. “…and the glory of Your people Israel”
God is not finished with Israel.
Simeon’s words affirm:
- Israel still has a future
- the promises still stand
- the covenants still matter
- the Messiah still belongs to Israel
Jesus is both:
- Israel’s glory
- the world’s Savior
5. Anna: Faithful Worship in the Waiting
Anna, an elderly prophetess, had spent decades worshiping, fasting, and praying in the temple.
When she sees the Child, she does not hesitate.
“She spoke of Him to all those who looked for redemption in Jerusalem.”
Waiting turned into witnessing.
Those who wait on God faithfully will always recognize Him when He moves.
Encouragement for Today
Simeon and Anna remind us:
- God’s promises are never forgotten
- God’s timing is always perfect
- God rewards patient, faithful trust
You may be waiting right now — for answers, for clarity, for relief, for fulfillment.
Christmas assures us that God always arrives right on time (Galatians 4:4).
The same God who kept His promises to Simeon and Anna will keep His promises to you.
Reading Plan
- Isaiah 40:1–5 — The Consolation of Israel
- Isaiah 49:6 — Light to the Gentiles
- Luke 2:25–38 — Simeon and Anna
- Romans 15:8–12 — Christ confirms the promises
← Previous | 📖 Series Home | Next→
by Jamie Pantastico | Dec 24, 2025 | Devotionals |
🎄 Part 8 — The Shepherds, a Savior, Glory to God
Key Text: Luke 2:8–14
“but the angel reassured them. “Don’t be afraid!” he said. “I bring you good news that will bring great joy to all people.”
“For there is born to you this day in the city of David a Savior, who is Christ the Lord.”
“Glory to God in the highest,
And on earth peace, goodwill toward men!”
Devotional: Heaven Speaks, the Lowly Hear
Theme Connection:
- Genesis 3:15 promised a Redeemer.
- 2 Samuel 7 promised a King.
- Luke 1:30–33 confirmed the throne, the kingdom, and the heir.
- Luke 2:8–14 reveals how God chose to announce this King to the world.
Not through royal courts.
Not through religious institutions.
But through angels — to shepherds — in the dark.
Context & Connection
Shepherds were watching their flocks by night in the fields surrounding Bethlehem — the very city where David once tended sheep before becoming king.
In that quiet, ordinary setting, heaven broke through:
“And behold, an angel of the Lord stood before them, and the glory of the Lord shone around them…”
Shepherds occupied the lowest social rung in Jewish society:
- ceremonially unclean
- untrusted as witnesses
- poor and unnoticed
- excluded from religious prestige
Yet God chose them as the first human witnesses of Christ’s birth.
This is no accident.
The gospel has always moved downward before it moves outward.
Devotional Insight
1. “Fear not…” — The First Word of the Gospel or Good News
The shepherds were terrified — and rightly so.
The glory of the Lord shattered the darkness.
But the angel’s first words are significant:
“Do not be afraid.”
The gospel always begins this way.
Before instruction.
Before commission.
Before celebration.
God removes fear.
Peace begins with God calming the human heart.
2. “For there is born to you…” — The Gospel Is Personal
This announcement was not abstract theology.
“…born to you this day…”
The Savior was not merely born into the world —
He was born for people.
For shepherds.
For sinners.
For the overlooked.
For you.
Christmas is personal before it is global.
3. “A Savior, who is Christ the Lord” — His Full Identity
In one sentence, heaven reveals everything:
- Savior — His mission
- Christ — the promised Messiah
- Lord — His divine authority
This Child is not merely a teacher or moral example.
He is God’s appointed Redeemer and rightful King.
The manger holds the One who will crush the serpent’s head and rule on David’s throne.
4. “Glory to God in the highest…” — Heaven’s Priority
Notice the order:
Glory to God first.
Peace to men second.
Redemption is not about human comfort first —
it is about God’s glory being restored.
When God is glorified, peace follows.
5. “On earth peace…” — What Kind of Peace?
This is not political peace.
Rome still ruled.
Oppression still existed.
Suffering would continue.
This is peace with God.
Paul later explains it clearly:
“Therefore, having been justified by faith, we have peace with God through our Lord Jesus Christ.” (Romans 5:1)
The angels announced the beginning of reconciliation — the undoing of Eden’s rupture.
Peace begins in the heart… and will one day fill the earth when the King returns.
Encouragement for Today
The shepherds remind us of a powerful truth:
God reveals His glory to the humble.
He meets people in ordinary places, in the middle of ordinary nights, doing ordinary work.
You don’t have to be important for God to speak to you.
You don’t have to be polished for God to use you.
You don’t have to be powerful for God to call you.
You just have to be willing to listen.
Christmas tells us this:
God came near.
God spoke clearly.
God brought peace.
And He still does.
Reading Plan
- Luke 2:8–20 — The shepherds respond
- Isaiah 53:6 — The Shepherd who bears sin
- John 10:11–18 — The Good Shepherd
- Romans 5:1 — Peace with God through Christ
← Previous | 📖 Series Home | Next→