PART 1 — Why the Church Is Turning Against Israel

by Jamie Pantastico | Jan 12, 2026 | Israel and Bible Prophecy | 0 comments

Prophetic Causes and Consequences

A Defining Moment: October 7, 2023

October 7, 2023, was not merely another tragic day in the Middle East. It was a moral and prophetic fault line.

On that day, Jewish civilians in Israel were subjected to unspeakable acts of brutality—mass murder, torture, rape, and abduction. These were not acts of war between armies; they were atrocities against families, children, and the elderly.

What followed should have been unambiguous moral clarity—especially from the Church.

Instead, October 7 exposed something far more alarming: a theological collapse already underway.

Within days, and then weeks, voices within Christendom—particularly in America—began reframing the massacre. Condemnation gave way to qualification. Sympathy gave way to suspicion. Moral outrage gave way to ideological narratives. The suffering of Jewish civilians was quickly eclipsed by accusations against Israel’s very existence.

This marked a turning point.

For decades, much of American Protestantism quietly held to replacement theology while maintaining public silence about modern Israel. Israel’s right to exist was generally left uncontested, even by those who believed the Church had replaced her spiritually.

After October 7, that restraint vanished.

Mainline Protestant denominations, pastors, theologians, and Christian commentators—many of whom had never spoken publicly against Israel or the Jewish people—now do so openly and aggressively. What was once implied is now explicit:

Israel has no biblical standing.
The Church is Israel.
The Jewish state is a theological error.

This shift did not originate from Scripture.
It originated from ideology.

And Scripture warned us this moment would come.

“All nations of the earth are gathered against it.”
— Zechariah 12:3

October 7 did not cause the Church’s turn against Israel.
It revealed it.

The event acted as a catalyst, pulling back the curtain on a theology that had long been present but rarely spoken aloud. In that sense, October 7 stands as a prophetic marker—not because of what Israel did or did not do afterward, but because of how the Church responded.

When moral clarity collapses after such evil, the issue is no longer political.
It is spiritual blindness.

This is why the Church is turning against Israel now—and why the consequences will not remain confined to theology.

A noticeable shift is taking place within the modern Church—and it is accelerating.

Christians who once affirmed God’s covenant with Israel are now questioning it. Others have moved beyond questioning and are openly opposing Israel, dismissing biblical prophecy, and framing support for the Jewish people as political, naïve, or even immoral.

This shift is not random.
It is not merely political.
And it is not accidental.

It is prophetic.

Scripture warned that this would happen—and it also warned of the consequences.

1. The Foundational Cause: Replacement Theology Has Returned

At the root of the Church’s growing hostility toward Israel is an old error with a new voice: Replacement Theology.

This doctrine teaches—explicitly or implicitly—that:

• Israel has forfeited her promises
• The Church has replaced Israel
• National Israel has no future in God’s plan
• Old Testament prophecies are spiritualized or reassigned

Yet Paul confronts this head-on:

“Has God cast away His people? Certainly not!”
— Romans 11:1

Replacement theology does not arise from Scripture—it arises from ignoring Romans 9–11, the very chapters written to prevent this error.

When the Church stops teaching these chapters, arrogance toward Israel always follows.

2. The Spiritual Cause: Israel Remains Central to God’s Prophetic Plan

Israel is not peripheral to prophecy—it is essential.

Consider what Scripture ties directly to Israel:

• The Second Coming of Christ (Zech. 12:10; Matt. 23:39)
• The Tribulation timeline (Dan. 9:24–27)
• The Millennial Kingdom (Isa. 2; Mic. 4; Zech. 14)
• The vindication of God’s name before the nations (Ezek. 36:22–23)

If Israel matters prophetically, then Satan’s opposition to Israel is unavoidable.

Hostility toward Israel is not merely ideological—it is spiritual warfare.

3. The Cultural Cause: The Church Has Adopted the World’s Moral Framework

Much of the modern Church now interprets the world through categories such as:

• Oppressor vs. oppressed
• Colonizer vs. colonized
• Power vs. victim

These categories are not biblical—they are ideological.

When this framework is applied, Israel is automatically cast as the villain, regardless of facts, history, or Scripture. Once Christians accept this lens, biblical truth becomes secondary to cultural approval.

“Do not be conformed to this world…”
— Romans 12:2

4. The Doctrinal Cause: Prophecy Has Been Mocked and Abandoned

Prophecy used to be taught carefully—even reverently.

Today it is:

• mocked as speculative
• dismissed as “fear-based”
• labeled divisive
• treated as irrelevant

Yet prophecy comprises nearly one-third of Scripture.

When prophecy is discarded, Israel becomes unintelligible—and when Israel becomes unintelligible, hostility follows.

5. The Historical Pattern: Theology Always Shapes Behavior

History is soberingly consistent:

When the Church affirms Israel → Jews are protected.
When the Church replaces Israel → Jews are persecuted.

From the early Church councils to the Reformation to 20th-century Europe, the pattern never changes.

Bad theology always produces real-world consequences.

6. The Prophetic Alignment: Zechariah 12 Is Coming into Focus

God declared:

“I will make Jerusalem a cup of trembling to all the surrounding peoples… and all nations of the earth will be gathered against it.”
— Zechariah 12:2–3 

This includes:

• Governments
• Institutions
• Media
• And yes—religious systems

The Church is not immune to this alignment if it abandons Scripture.

7. The Consequence: A Dividing Line Is Being Drawn

Two expressions of Christianity are emerging:

The Remnant

• Honors Scripture
• Recognizes Israel’s role
• Teaches prophecy
• Upholds Paul’s gospel
• Walks in humility

The Apostate

• Spiritualizes Scripture
• Rejects Israel
• Mocks prophecy
• Blends with culture
• Embraces arrogance

Paul warned Gentile believers:

“Do not boast against the branches… remember that you do not support the root, but the root supports you.”
— Romans 11:18

Conclusion: Why This Matters Now

This is not an academic debate.
This is a test of faithfulness.

How the Church responds to Israel reveals how it handles:

• Scripture
• Covenant
• Prophecy
• Authority
• Humility

The turning of the Church against Israel is not a sign of enlightenment—it is a sign of drift.

And drift always precedes judgment.

Explore the Series
← Previous | 📖 Series Home | Next →